We care about your privacy and data security. We use essential cookies to ensure our website functions properly and securely. Analytical and marketing cookies are used only with your consent. For more information, see our Privacy Policy and Website Terms.

+48 71 880 85 08
Mon–Fri - 09:00 to 17:00
Sat - by appointment
  1. Home
  2. Cases
  3. Permanent residence application rejected for “illegal stay”: the second instance overturned the voivode

Cases

Practical guides on legalization: cities, procedures and typical situations.

Permanent residence application rejected for “illegal stay”: the second instance overturned the voivode

Permanent residence application rejected for “illegal stay”: the second instance overturned the voivode
Viewed: 1
22.11.2026

Short answer

The voivode refused to open permanent residence proceedings for a Ukrainian citizen, claiming he was staying in Poland illegally. We filed a complaint and the Office for Foreigners overturned the ruling in full. In parallel the client obtained a residence permit based on business.

Sometimes the office does not refuse on the merits. It refuses at the door and does not examine the application at all. The wording sounds harsh: “the foreigner is staying in Poland illegally.” In this case we were sure the inspector had misread the law, and the second instance confirmed it.

What the client came to us with

A Ukrainian citizen has lived in Poland for several years. He had already applied for permanent residence based on Polish ancestry and was refused after failing the interview. He came to us to apply again and to prepare properly this time.

We filed the new permanent residence application on 24 September 2025.

A refusal that should not have happened

Before deciding, the inspector asked us to explain on what basis the client was staying in Poland. We answered in detail, with references to the law. In our assessment the stay was legal and there was no room for doubt.

Even so, on 18 December 2025 the voivode issued a ruling refusing to open the proceedings. The reasoning was this: the earlier refusal had become final, so from that day the person was in Poland without a right to stay, and a permanent residence application cannot be filed during an illegal stay.

What we did

There are only 7 days to challenge this kind of ruling. It was delivered to us on 5 January 2026, and on 9 January the complaint was already on its way to the second instance. As part of the appeal against the refusal we:

  • showed that the client’s deadline to leave Poland had been extended under the Act on assistance to Ukrainian citizens;
  • pointed to the provision of the Act on Foreigners under which a stay during such an extended deadline is treated as legal;
  • proved that the voivode had misinterpreted the law and therefore wrongly applied the ground for refusal;
  • handled all correspondence with the voivodeship office and the Office for Foreigners on the client’s behalf.

“When an inspector writes ‘illegal stay’, many people give up. What you need to do is open the statute and check every date. In this case the mistake was not the client’s. It was in how the provision was read. We saw it at the explanation stage, so we went to the second instance with confidence.”

Tetiana Vyborna, ONE PLUS

Result

On 11 February 2026 the Head of the Office for Foreigners overturned the voivode’s ruling in full. The second instance stated that during the extended deadline to leave Poland the foreigner’s stay was treated as legal, and that the voivode had misinterpreted the Act on assistance to Ukrainian citizens. There was no basis to refuse to open the proceedings.

The permanent residence application went back to be examined on the merits. A little over a month passed between the complaint and the reversal.

Plan B: a residence permit based on business

The client needed a document in hand, not just a won argument. So we did not wait for the outcome and filed a parallel application for a residence permit based on business activity. It ended with a positive decision. The client now holds a residence card while the main case continues.

How the client followed the case

The client was connected to the ONE PLUS online CRM. In his account he could see both cases, the documents filed and the replies from the authorities, and he got an SMS at every stage: the inspector’s request, our reply, the refusal, the complaint, the reversal. The same account gives access to discounts on further ONE PLUS services.

Rating:
Click to rate this post!
[Total: 0 Average: 0]
Keywords:
Wrocław Permanent residence, refusal, illegal stay, Office for Foreigners, Wrocław Appeal / Permanent residence / February 2026
FAQ

Frequently asked questions

Short answers to questions that most often come up in similar cases.
How is a refusal to open proceedings different from a regular refusal?

With a regular refusal the office examined the application and found the conditions were not met. With a refusal to open proceedings the application is not examined at all, for example because the stay is considered illegal. The remedy and the deadline are different too.

How long do I have to challenge such a ruling?

7 days from delivery. That is half the time allowed for appealing a regular decision, so you need to act at once.

Can I file a second application while the first one is in dispute?

Yes, if it has its own basis: work, business, studies or family. In this case the second basis was business activity.

What should I do if the office says my stay is illegal?

Do not accept it automatically. Check every date: when your previous document expired, when decisions became final and whether special rules apply to you. We help with this as part of our residence permit service in Wrocław.